I've bought the SkyRise tent almost four years ago now, so here's the review I wish I saw before I bought.
The pros:
This tent is a fraction of the cost of other rooftop tents on the market. The metal frame which becomes the base of the tent is sturdy and reliable, the fabric is still just as waterproof as the first use (the rainfly has withstood some pretty hefty storms and kept me nice and dry), the ladder collapses and extends just as well now, the cover fits and stays secure just as well now, and the mattress is just as comfortable. THE best part about this tent imho is the clear window on the rainfly which goes over the mesh window above your head. YES, Yakima! This is the kind of thoughtful wizardry that's so appreciated. I'm not sure how this tent stacks up against others in terms of gas mileage, but I've noticed that this cover stays fairly tight to the tent instead of ballooning up on the road like a few other brands do. Also, it really is comfortable and spacious inside. My partner, me, and our German Shepherd fit with room to spare. I expect to use this tent for many more years without problems.
The cons:
I will say that every downfall I've noticed about this tent is more of an inconvenience than a pitfall. First, it takes significantly longer to set up than other RTT. I've got long legs and arms, but this tent requires my furthest reach and wonkiest maneuvering around the roof of my car to set up and take down. The cover is easy enough to unbuckle and rip off the velcro, but the straps to roll it up into are pretty short so it takes some work. The ladder is secured by a velcro strap and then needs to be pushed out from the top so that it can be pulled to open the tent up. This is one of the awkward movements. One weird thing: the middle of the tent where the top and bottom meet when it opens up are covered by two flaps of fabric, but are more or less open, 5-inch gaps on either side of the tent. Not a big deal, but I think it needs a better solution.
My biggest qualm is the poles for the rainfly. These puppies are HIGH tension between the tent frame and the rainfly grommet. First, it goes through an opening in the tent and into a tiny hole in the frame, then it needs to be bent (like what, 90 degrees?) to stick the other end in the rainfly. I cannot tell you how awkward this is to do at this height and in these certain positions. Sometimes it's easiest to do from inside the tent, but I'm still figuring out the most efficient strategy to get these guys set up. LMK if anyone has a good method! Another thing I saw in reviews before I bought the tent, which unfortunately is true: the black rubber ends will fall off the rainfly poles the first time you use them. And yes, they're nice and sharp underneath. My last inconvenience with this tent: the ladder needs to be straight up and down, or the edges hurt your feet :) Also, in reverse, it's just as awkward to take down.
One reviewer says this tent is not heavy--I don't know how heavy other tents are, but to get this on and off a car you need two very strong, tall people, or four normal people. Not a huge thing, and I'm glad she's sturdy, but definitely NOT light.
OVERALL-
I love this tent. It is part of my personality. It will be with me for many years. But I hope yakima makes some adjustments to the next version to make setup and takedown a lil less awkward. Also @yakima! Can you make a dog attachment for the ladder? Perhaps a lil ramp?